VOTES / CIP-0060

Super Validators executed 3 DSO vote requests whose stated reasoning cites this CIP. This is the ledger record, so it says what was carried out rather than what was discussed.

• 2025-12-16 · Create unclaimed activity record (zerohash-validator-1) · Accepted 12 for / 0 against
• 2025-12-12 · Create unclaimed activity record (zerohash-validator-1) · Accepted 13 for / 0 against
• 2025-12-05 · Create unclaimed activity record (zh-treasury) · Accepted 13 for / 0 against

Positions are parsed from each message's body text (most are one-line statements like "Five North in favor"). If parsing was uncertain, the row appears as position unclear below — please flag if you spot a misread.

• in favor
  DrAmandaLMartin

  Hello Super Validator Node Owners,   Please find CIP-0060: Add Zero Hash as SV of Weight 10 ready for vote https://github.com/global-synchronizer-foundation/cips/pull/53   Digital Asset - SV Sponsor 5North  - SV Endorser All other's please list: <SV Name> votes <in favor | not in favor> Dr. Amanda L. Martin 814-359-6544 The Linux Foundation Director of Program Management Github  | LinkedIn 

  2025-04-24 11:02 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• in favor
  Tradeweb votes

  Tradeweb votes in favor   toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-01 21:11 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• in favor
  MPCH is

  MPCH is in favor   Kinga Z. Bosse COO|MPCH|www.mpch.com Book time to meet with me     From: cip-vote@... <cip-vote@...> on behalf of Justin Peterson via lists.sync.global <justin.peterson=tradeweb.com@...> Date: Thursday, May 1, 2025 at 5:11 PM To: cip-vote@... <cip-vote@...> Subject: Re: [cip-votes] CIP-0060: Add Zero Hash as SV of Weight 10 Tradeweb votes in favor   toggle quoted m

  2025-05-01 21:22 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• in favor
  Cumberland DRW votes not

  Cumberland DRW votes not in favor. We believe that the potential weight awards is too high particularly relative to the volume thresholds. The concept behind the CIP is something we can potentially be supportive of with some re-calibration of the weight/threshold criteria. I think a conversation during tomorrow’s call is merited. Thanks Chris toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-01 21:33 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• in favor
  Orb1 votes not

  Orb1 votes not in favor for the same reasoning as DRW.

  2025-05-01 22:09 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• position unclear
  Chris Matturri

  Proof Group also votes no to this current proposal.  We support the idea of Zero Hash joining and contributing to the network but would like to see tighter milestones from them on a consistent volume perspective.  Happy to chat with them and help craft a new CIP to encourage more recurring volume settled specifically on Canton.  toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-02 01:43 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• position unclear
  Aman Goyal

  SBI is withholding its vote until further clarity on why a weight of 10 is proposed for Zero Hash given that they would be joining as a 'KPI-based contributor in kind'. toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-02 04:11 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• in favor
  Veronica Augustsson

  C7/7RIDGE votes not in favor for the same reasons. Veronica   V E R O N I C A   A U G U S T S S O N   /   P A R T N E R ​ 7RIDGE IS A PRIVATE MARKETS ASSET MANAGER INVESTED IN TRANSFORMATIVE TECHNOLOGY FOR FINANCIAL SERVICES TO POWER THE GLOBAL ECONOMY Signature for V e r o n i c a A u g u s t s s o n      toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-02 05:32 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• position unclear
  Chris Zuehlke

  All -    Following our discussion regarding this CIP, I wanted to present some modifications for the group to consider for subsequent vote.  If you would prefer I posted this in cip-discuss, please let me know and I will.  Given this proposal is in response to the original vote, I thought it most appropriate to post here. Following the previous structure:     (NO CHANGE) Zero Hash ("ZH") Product

  2025-05-06 22:13 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• position unclear
  Yiannis Varelas

  Hi Chris, Thanks for putting this together—Five North is supportive of the modifications. I believe the tiered, stepwise incentive model and the 24-month timeframe align well with the network's goal  and also provide ZeroHash sufficient space to drive volume as they scale their business. If they manage to drive volume sooner, still great for everyone.  Y. toggle quoted message Show quot

  2025-05-07 11:33 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• position unclear
  Thank you

  Thank you for sharing Chris and the thoughtful work your team put into this. Proof Group really likes the idea of creating milestones for having ZeroHash make Canton its exclusive privacy focused chain & increasing the volume incentives + carrying them out to 2 full years.   We are happy to sponsor this for a vote if needed.   toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-07 15:14 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• position unclear
  Chris Zuehlke

  All -    Yiannis and I had a chance to speak with Edward from ZH earlier today and talked through the proposal changes.  He shared some feedback, portions of which I think merit some changes to what I proposed a few days ago.  Based on his feedback, I believe they are ready to accept the following (including the standard KPI/escrow structure, etc.)   For avoidance of doubt, I reposted each of the

  2025-05-08 21:23 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• position unclear
  Eric Saraniecki

  thank you Zuehlke & Yiannis  Looks like a positive construct to me @ Amanda - would you please update the CIP and then we can proceed with the vote? toggle quoted message Show quoted text -- W. Eric Saraniecki Co-founder / +1 773 719 1983 Digital Asset, creators of Daml This message, and any attachments, is for the intended recipient(s) only, may contain information that is privileg

  2025-05-08 21:26 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• position unclear
  Chris Matturri

  Thank you Chris & Yiannis- appreciate you guys speaking with Ed to get these changes over the line.   Aligns well with their volume + customer onboarding incentives.  Proof Group will support this with our vote.  toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-08 23:27 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• in favor
  DrAmandaLMartin

  Hello Super Validator Node Owners,   Please find CIP-0060: Add Zero Hash as SV of Weight 10 ready for vote on the second proposal https://github.com/global-synchronizer-foundation/cips/blob/cip-0060/cip-0060/cip-0060.md Digital Asset - SV Sponsor 5North  - SV Endorser All other's please list: <SV Name> votes <in favor | not in favor> Dr. Amanda L. Martin 814-359-6544 The Linux Foundation

  2025-05-10 11:01 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• position unclear
  Eric Saraniecki

  Hi Amanda - can you change the email and header as the total weight is now 7.5 (I believe) please ? toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-10 11:21 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• position unclear
  Thanks

  Thanks for letting me know. All changed! Dr. Amanda L. Martin 814-359-6544 The Linux Foundation Director of Program Management Github  | LinkedIn  | Calendar toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-12 06:54 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• in favor
  Yiannis Varelas

  Hi all - I'm confused so please excuse me. Are we moving forward with this as a fresh vote or we just wait for the rest of the SVs to vote? Thanks. On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 2:54 AM DrAmandaLMartin via lists.sync.global <amartin=linuxfoundation.org@...> wrote: Thanks for letting me know. All changed! Dr. Amanda L. Martin 814-359-6544 The Linux Foundation Director of Program Management Github

  2025-05-13 15:15 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• in favor
  DrAmandaLMartin

  We are conducting a new vote since this is resubmitted.  So far the voting is below, I logged your vote even though it technical happened before it opened again :) Proof Group - in favor Digital Asset - Sponsor 5North - Endorser Dr. Amanda L. Martin 814-359-6544 The Linux Foundation Director of Program Management Github  | LinkedIn  | Calendar toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-13 15:17 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• position unclear
  Yiannis Varelas

  Thank you Amanda!  toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-13 15:18 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• in favor
  Cumberland DRW votes

  Cumberland DRW votes in favor.   toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-13 15:28 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• in favor
  Tradeweb votes

  Tradeweb votes in favor.   toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-13 15:36 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• in favor
  MPCH votes

  MPCH votes in favor   Kinga Z. Bosse COO|MPCH|www.mpch.com Book time to meet with me     From: cip-vote@... <cip-vote@...> on behalf of Chris Zuehlke via lists.sync.global <czuehlke=drwholdings.com@...> Date: Tuesday, May 13, 2025 at 11:28 AM To: cip-vote@... <cip-vote@...> Subject: Re: [cip-votes] CIP-0060: Add Zero Hash as SV of Weight 7.5 Cumberland DRW votes in favor.   toggle qu

  2025-05-13 15:52 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• position unclear
  Chris Matturri

  Not sure if my email earlier counted- but Proof Group votes yes for ZeroHash's SV  toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-13 17:19 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• position unclear
  Veronica Augustsson

  7RIDGE/C7 votes in favour   Veronica     V E R O N I C A   A U G U S T S S O N   /   P A R T N E R ​ 7RIDGE IS A PRIVATE MARKETS ASSET MANAGER INVESTED IN TRANSFORMATIVE TECHNOLOGY FOR FINANCIAL SERVICES TO POWER THE GLOBAL ECONOMY Signature for V e r o n i c a A u g u s t s s o n      toggle quoted message Show quoted text

  2025-05-13 20:07 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• in favor
  MPCH is

  MPCH is in favor.

  2025-05-13 20:12 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• position unclear
  MPCH votes

  MPCH votes yes.

  2025-05-13 20:13 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗
• in favor
  MPCH is

  MPCH is in favor

  2025-05-13 20:14 UTC · open on lists.sync.global ↗

Same data through MCP:

• get_cip_votes({cip_id: "0060"}) — formatted markdown of each vote message in chronological order.
• get_cip_citations — full citation graph (includes the same vote messages plus everything else that references this CIP).
• get_cip_history — status transitions over time (/governance/timeline).
• GET /api/v1/cips/0060/mentions — aggregated backlinks (includes mailing-thread references).